I didn’t know how many parts were going to be to this article, and I think it is fitting that it landed on the number seven the number of perfection in the Bible. I don’t know if this testimony is going to be perfect but I will try my best, let me again, reiterate that I do not have an ax to grind, nor do I hold any ill will toward anyone at Calvary Chapel, including the pastors there that did me wrong. I have since forgiven them and left them in God’s hands. My hope is that they one day, they repent, and forsake the teachings of Chuck Smith and that true change would come to the government structure of Calvary Chapel so that safeguards are put in place to hold leaders accountable and so congregants don’t get hurt or spiritually abused by these leaders.
How I got there
I will try to keep this short for blog space so that I can post this on social media and comments.
It all started out with me, leading a family to the Lord that had no church to go to. The church that I attended was too far for them to go, so I tried to help them find a church close to them. I was having a conversation at work, with someone who I had heard was a Christian and I told her my dilemma, and she immediately said that she attended a Calvary chapel and that they were a very good church. I got the contact information and called the Church office and spoke with the secretary, and got the information for my friends.
I went to a Bible study with the husband of the family that I was trying to find a home Church for and it was run by a Calvary chapel assistant pastor, who I will call Pastor a. pastor a was very Charismatic, and friendly we were welcomed into the group quite quickly. I was impressed at the Bible study. They had been going over Bible drills and finding Bible verses about different subjects all over the Bible. It was overwhelmingly challenging to find all those passages of scripture, but I was impressed at the challenge. After the Bible study, I talked to Pastor along with the husband of the family. I was trying to find a church and we both liked Pastor a and we were both convinced that Calvary Chapel was the right place for my friend and his family.
Fast-forward a couple months into my friends, attending a Calvary chapel tragedy struck my family and my wife and I separated. I didn’t feel comfortable going to the same church as her so I started attending the Calvary chapel where I had brought my friends.
Pastor a and many others overwhelmed me with love and attention, and I immediately began volunteering for the setting up and breaking down of the chairs and the PA system for Sunday services because they were meeting in a middle school gym, so everything had to be set up and broken down at the end of each Sunday service.
One thing I noticed, straight away, was that they were very rigid about how things were to be set up. The chairs had to be exactly perfect. Cords from the PA system had to be wound a certain way, which I found silly because with my musical background, I knew how to take care of PA system cords, but I did not mind being humble and taking direction. The first red flag I should have noticed was in the very beginning when Pastor a chastised a couple for not doing the snack table perfectly, and he threatened them that if they could not get it right that they would no longer be allowed to do it. I shook it off as maybe Pastor a was just having a bad day but I witnessed other behaviors like this from other leaders in the ministry. Once, during set up time, I witnessed the worship leader hollering at one of the volunteers. I don’t remember exactly what was said, but I remember feeling that the worship leader was being really irrational and unfair to this volunteer. So me with my bold, big mouth stepped in, and I told him to chill out. He seems shocked that I had confronted him like that and he immediately refrained.
I immediately started sitting under the counseling of Pastor a as well as one other senior church member. I was really in a bad place in my life with the separation from my wife and other emotional issues that I was carrying. I stayed briefly with Pastor a at his home, while I was separated from my wife. While I considered Pastor a to be a good friend, I was not impressed by him as a pastor, because he was single and not the husband of one wife, as the New Testament clearly defines a pastor, but I looked past it anyway, because I considered him to be a good friend. In the short time that I lived with him, which was only about a couple weeks, I witnessed him being manipulative in someways at Bible studies concerning the scriptures and towardsother congregants. He would say things about the scriptures like “we can never really know for sure” “everything is relative” The first statement he made is very similar to what the devil said to Eve in the garden of Eden when he caused her to question God and that’s basically what that statement was doing. And the statement about everything being relative is a secular statement and not biblical at all, everything is not relative it is either true or untrue. Also, while I was living with him, he confided in me that he was purposely trying to manipulate his boss so that he could do full-time ministry. This was a very troubling statement as most mature Christians know that God is the one who opens the doors to ministry, not us. I also found this statement to be very immature but again I was going through my own troubles, so I overlooked it. looking back I was overwhelmed by the false sense of love and acceptance that he and others had shown me, and it clouded my better judgment.
I continue to spend months partnering with Pastor an and other pastors in street ministry and other activities. Pastor a asked me a question that really shocked me and took me back or really it was a statement. He said that I should be a Calvary Chapel pastor because of my evangelistic abilities. I told him that I was in no place to do such a thing because I was separated from my wife and also because I felt that was not my calling to be a pastor. Pastor a did not leave it alone at that point, but persisted by bringing me into the inner circle of that Calvary Chapel. Aside from setting up and breaking down for the services on Sunday morning they put me in charge of counting the tithes. I remember counting the money one Sunday and realizing that out of approximately 40 people my offering had accounted for about 20% of the total offering. It seemed that the attendees here were not very disciplined about tithing. Not soon after that Pastor a and now another pastor I will name Pastor B came to me and confirmed my thoughts. They said that they were going to change the name of the Calvary chapel to Calvary Chapel_______. they said they wanted to do this to create more enthusiasm in the congregation, but implied that there would be a positive financial side to this name change. they charge me to keep this move a secret and not reveal it to anybody.
The beginning of the end
As I was doing street, ministry and Bible studies with pastor a I realized his presentation of the gospel was really weak. Now at that time I had just discovered myself about what the true and proper gospel should be through Ray Comfort videos on YouTube. When I confronted him about his presentation of the gospel he said “we’re all about love man”. When I told him the Bible says to speak the truth in love, which means preaching a gospel that talks about sin, judgment, repentance, and faith, he seemed baffled. One of my favorite preachers who is now deceased named Derek Prince, one said, “if all a group preaches about is love you can be sure there is something wrong with their doctrine” and Derek would be correct, because there were things wrong with their doctrine that I would later question. The thing that we need to understand is that there is no true love without truth, and I found this to be true with other passages of scripture that he twisted or skipped over altogether. One such passage that he skipped over, was the passage and Matthew where Jesus said no one knows the day or the hour that Christ would return. This passage is pivotal because Chuck Smith had made a prophecy in 1978 and one of his books that Jesus would return in 1981 when I confronted him about this at the Bible study. He became very combative and said, “are you challenging me”? It may not seem like such a big deal to anyone else, but Calvary Chapel and their pastors prided themselves on teaching the scriptures chapter by chapter verse by verse, so I found it very odd that they skipped this passage while reading from Matthew. One of the congregants that was helping with the Bible study just blurted out “What about love Rich?”And I explained to him that without truth, there is no love at least not real love anyway. During my time here I witnessed a lot of sinful behaviors amongst Calvary chapel attendees and it seemed that the sinful behaviors were tolerated in the name of love. When I asked Pastor a why this was, he told me “not to judge, and that God would deal with them”. But let’s look at what the Bible says about this very subject of Christians, who are in sin and what we are truly supposed to do, not just leave them on an island but to help them.
Galatians 6:1-2 KJV
Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted. [2] Bear ye one another’s burdens, and so fulfil the law of Christ.
So, as you can see, this is totally un biblical advice.
Rewind I will share another incident that raised the red flag towards the end, when I started to become wise to the false gospel, teaching, the twisting of scriptures and the emotional gaslighting that I had endured during my time at Calvary Chapel. Pastor a was just leaving a Bible study that we had both gone to, and a female congregant pulled up in her car. she was looking at some apartments and wanted Pastor a to come along with her to look at some apartments. He got into her car, and they went off together a single pastor and a single congregant alone in a car. when I asked him about this the next day, and tried to admonish him that this was not a good idea that he should be alone with a single woman, and that he should’ve taken his own car and met her there, he said “I am a pastor I have special privileges”. This is something a cult leader would say because they feel they are beyond reproach. It was like somehow he was saying that the Bible did not apply to him. I learned this concept from Billy Graham that he said he would never be alone with a woman other than his wife without his wife being present. This is what the Bible has to say about the situation.
1 Thessalonians 5:22 KJV Abstain from all appearance of evil.
This is the verse that Billy Graham had based the integrity of his entire ministry on, and Pastor a just mocked that verse when I quoted it to him.
Fast-forward back to the time I was talking about the Bible study on which I had confronted Pastor a about the passage in Matthew that he skipped over concerning what Jesus said about no one knows the day or the hour. When the person who is assisting with the Bible study interjected, it became a free for all. Both him and Pastor a were very angry that I had questioned Chuck Smith’s teaching and said that I wasn’t being loving. This lead to an uproar of confusion with the family that I had brought to Calvary Chapel, who were in attendance at the Bible study. This is a little bit of a rabbit trail, but this just came back to my memory. Pastor a had given his testimony at a previous Bible study and it was full of gaslighting tactics. He told the story of how he was suicidal, and how sad his story was, and how Jesus changed his life, which was all fine and good but his testimony did not include the gospel or anything close to it. He just said Jesus changed my life. Looking back on that testimony I realize that he was trying to manipulate people into feeling sorry for him so that they would be easier to manipulate, this type of testimony appeals to the emotions, but has no biblical worth, especially when you don’t include the gospel or how the gospel saved your life.
At this time I had already been questioning Calvary Chapel doctrines, and practices, and raising my concerns about them, especially the preaching of the gospel.
One Sunday after we got done breaking down the set up for Sunday service a pastor who I will call Pastor B pulled me aside and invited me to lunch. I had already had lunch plans, but I did not want to be rude, so I agreed to go. When we got to the restaurant, we sat down and he immediately tore into me, saying how dare I challenge Pastor a and the teachings of Chuck Smith and that I needed to repent of being a detractor or negative person. I didn’t know this at the time, but the word detractor is a cult term. I am not saying the Calvary chapels are a cult, but they do have many Cultic tendencies, because of the Moses model, and the danger of narcissistic leaders who answer to no one ruling over the congregation.Long story short, he accused me of being in sin, and that I needed to repent. He even read a scripture that he twisted the meaning of and it was a scripture that I had read many times in my king James Bible, but he read it out of one of the modern versions and twisted the verses meaning altogether to make it seem like I was the one who was an error. When I corrected him he did not like that and he told me to leave Calvary Chapel and never come back or he would call the police, so supposedly I was in sin, the proper protocol for that would have been Matthew 18 where if he thought I was in sin he should’ve brought two witnesses to rebuke me and then if I didn’t listen, they should’ve brought me in front of the congregation and let them judge. But he knew he was wrong, and that’s why they didn’t do that and quite honestly I don’t think they had that kind of government in place because like I said, they practiced the Moses model where one guy made all decisions and was the main guy in charge. I left that lunch, shocked and bewildered and I really didn’t know how to respond. I took a couple weeks off from going to Calvary Chapel and I prayed on it. The conclusion that I came to was that I could not let Pastor a and Pastor b just sweep me under the rug, and the wrong that they had done to me.They needed to be held accountable for their ungodly behavior.
This is when one Sunday I decided I would confront them about this in front of the congregation. I would have tried addressing congregants one on one, but they had already shunned me at this point. In hindsight, I am not sure that was the right thing to do, because it seemed that my friends who I had brought to that church had pushed me away even further after I did it. And instead of being honest about their ungodly behavior, and having an open dialogue in front of the congregation, Pastor B made good on his promise and he called the police on me but the police let me go because they had decided that I had broken no law. From what I have heard this is a common practice of Calvary chapels when someone speaks up and comes against leader ship that they get the legal system involved to try to shut you up. I was devastated at what happened to me and the spiritual abuse that I suffered and it took many years for me to open up to people again.I eventually reconciled with my wife, although the marriage counseling advice that I got from Pastor a nearly destroyed my marriage. Thank God my wife forgave me and took me back.Today I am a thriving family man, evangelist and musician who loves to share the gospel of Christ with as many people as I can. I forgive Pastor a and Pastor B and others that hurt me while I was there at Calvary Chapel. I pray that they will repent and stop hurting people. This is just not my testimony, but the testimony of thousands of people who have attended Calvary chapels across the country. This Moses model system needs to change to a new testament style of government that has checks and balances and holds leaders accountable. Again I am not attacking the people of Calvary Chapel. As a matter of fact, I love them and have so much compassion for them that I pray for them every day, my hope is that true change would come to Calvary Chapel or that people would come out from under that movement and find true Bible believing churches. The reason I waited so long to write this article was because I have been blogging for a couple years now, and really just wanted to avoid the subject altogether out of fear of legal repercussions from Calvary Chapel and hurting people at Calvary Chapel. But sometimes the truth hurts and I really care about those people and that is the reason that I am sounding the alarm, so that no, nobody else has to go through what I went through or even worse. I hope this article bless you in so many ways even if you don’t agree with the content of this article, I would ask you to pray on it and do some research of your own. I have given you most of my resources that I used in each portion of this article. Please check out my sources and know that I am telling the truth. Until then, God bless you in Jesus name.
2 Peter 2:1-3 KJV
But there were false prophets also among the people, even as there shall be false teachers among you, who privily shall bring in damnable heresies, even denying the Lord that bought them, and bring upon themselves swift destruction. [2] And many shall follow their pernicious ways; by reason of whom the way of truth shall be evil spoken of. [3] And through covetousness shall they with feigned words make merchandise of you: whose judgment now of a long time lingereth not, and their damnation slumbereth not.





